Since I share historical news and genealogy tips with awesome people like you, I want you to know that my content may contain affiliate links for products I use and love. If you take action (i.e. subscribe, make a purchase) after clicking on one of these links, I'll earn some coffee money which I promise to drink while creating more helpful content like this!

Saturday, November 18, 2023

Unwrapping American Thanksgiving: Myths, Legends, and Truths Behind the Feast


Ah, Thanksgiving—a time for family gatherings, feasting, and expressions of gratitude. As we prepare to indulge in a cornucopia of delicious dishes, it's worth taking a moment to unravel the myths, explore the legends, and discover the truths that surround this beloved holiday. Join me on a journey through the history of Thanksgiving, from its mythical origins to the truths that have shaped our modern celebrations.

    The Mythical Beginnings

    The story of Thanksgiving often begins with the Pilgrims and the Native Americans sharing a bountiful feast in 1621. While this tale has become an integral part of Thanksgiving lore, it's essential to recognize the nuances and myths that have woven themselves into the fabric of our collective memory.

    Myth: The First Thanksgiving Was a Formal, Annual Event

    Contrary to popular belief, the Pilgrims did not establish Thanksgiving as an annual tradition immediately after their 1621 feast. The event was a one-time gathering to celebrate a successful harvest and strengthen the bond between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag tribe. It wasn't until decades later that the concept of a recurring Thanksgiving feast took root.

    Legend: The Turkey as the Centerpiece

    Legend has it that the Pilgrims and Native Americans feasted on turkey during that inaugural Thanksgiving meal. While turkey is now synonymous with Thanksgiving, historical records suggest that the menu likely included a variety of meats, such as deer, fowl, and seafood. The turkey's rise to prominence in the Thanksgiving narrative is a later development that has endured over the centuries.

    The Evolution of Thanksgiving

    As the years passed, Thanksgiving evolved, influenced by historical events, cultural shifts, and presidential proclamations. Let's explore how this humble feast transformed into the cherished holiday we celebrate today.

    Truth: Thanksgiving Was Not Always a National Holiday

    Despite the popular image of the Pilgrims and Native Americans gathered around a festive table, Thanksgiving did not become a national holiday until the 19th century. In 1863, President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed Thanksgiving a national holiday, setting the stage for the annual tradition we know today.

    Myth: Thanksgiving Has Always Been About Turkey and Football

    While turkey and football have become integral parts of contemporary Thanksgiving celebrations, they weren't always synonymous with the holiday. Early Thanksgiving meals featured a diverse array of foods, and the association with football didn't solidify until the 20th century. Today, Thanksgiving Day football games are as much a tradition as the feast itself.

    Legend: The Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade

    The Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade is a legendary spectacle that has captivated audiences for nearly a century. What began as a small procession of Macy's employees in 1924 has evolved into a grand event featuring giant balloons, floats, and performances. The parade has become a beloved Thanksgiving tradition, marking the official start of the holiday season.

    Thanksgiving Myths and Misconceptions

    As with any long-standing tradition, Thanksgiving has accumulated its fair share of myths and misconceptions. Let's debunk some common misunderstandings and shed light on the truths behind the holiday.

    Myth: Thanksgiving is About Pilgrims Giving Thanks for a Bountiful Harvest

    While giving thanks for a plentiful harvest is a central theme of Thanksgiving, the holiday has evolved to encompass broader expressions of gratitude. Today, people give thanks for family, friends, and the blessings in their lives. Thanksgiving has become a time to reflect on the positive aspects of life and express appreciation for the people and experiences that enrich our existence.

    Truth: Not Everyone Celebrates Thanksgiving the Same Way

    Thanksgiving is a deeply ingrained tradition in American culture, but not everyone observes it in the same manner. Some individuals and communities choose to celebrate Thanksgiving in alternative ways, whether through cultural traditions, volunteer work, or quiet reflection. Recognizing and respecting diverse expressions of gratitude adds depth to the tapestry of Thanksgiving celebrations.

    Legend: The Pilgrims and Native Americans Lived in Harmony

    The image of Pilgrims and Native Americans peacefully coexisting has been romanticized over the years. While the 1621 feast did represent a moment of collaboration and goodwill, it's essential to acknowledge the complex and often tumultuous history between European settlers and Native American communities. Understanding the nuanced relationships that unfolded during this period provides a more accurate perspective on the historical context of Thanksgiving.

    Modern Thanksgiving Traditions

    As Thanksgiving has evolved, so too have the traditions that accompany it. From the iconic Macy's Parade to the quintessential turkey dinner, let's delve into the customs that define our modern celebrations.

    Truth: Black Friday is Now Part of the Thanksgiving Tradition

    In recent years, the line between Thanksgiving and the start of the holiday shopping season has blurred with the advent of Black Friday. Once reserved for the day after Thanksgiving, Black Friday sales now often begin on Thanksgiving Day itself. This shift has sparked debates about the impact on family time and the encroachment of consumerism into the holiday.

    Myth: Turkey is the Only Star of the Thanksgiving Table

    While the turkey is undoubtedly the centerpiece of many Thanksgiving feasts, modern celebrations often feature a diverse array of dishes. From classic sides like mashed potatoes and stuffing to innovative creations that reflect regional and cultural influences, Thanksgiving menus have become a dynamic and evolving reflection of individual tastes and traditions.

    Legend: Friendsgiving

    In recent years, Friendsgiving has emerged as a popular and inclusive way to celebrate Thanksgiving with friends. This informal gathering often takes place before or after the official holiday, allowing people to share a meal and express gratitude in the company of chosen family. Friendsgiving highlights the flexibility and adaptability of Thanksgiving traditions in the modern era.

    Dispelling Common Thanksgiving Misconceptions

    As we navigate the complexities of Thanksgiving history, it's essential to dispel some common misconceptions that persist in popular culture.

    Myth: The Pilgrims Landed at Plymouth Rock

    The story of the Pilgrims landing at Plymouth Rock has become a foundational element of American history. However, historical evidence suggests that the Pilgrims likely landed a bit north of Plymouth Rock, and the iconic rock itself only gained significance centuries later. The precise location of their landing remains a subject of historical debate.

    Truth: Thanksgiving Was Not Always a Fixed Date

    In the early years of American history, Thanksgiving was not celebrated on a fixed date. It was often declared by individual states or communities, leading to a lack of uniformity in the timing of the holiday. It wasn't until 1941 that Thanksgiving was officially designated as the fourth Thursday in November.

    Legend: The Presidential Turkey Pardon

    The tradition of the presidential turkey pardon, where the sitting president spares a turkey from becoming Thanksgiving dinner, is often traced back to President Abraham Lincoln. While there are stories of Lincoln's clemency towards a turkey, the modern tradition did not take root until the 20th century. President Harry Truman is credited with receiving the first ceremonial turkey in 1947, solidifying the connection between the president and the Thanksgiving bird.


    As we gather around the Thanksgiving table, let's appreciate the rich tapestry of myths, legends, and truths that have shaped this beloved holiday. From its mythical beginnings to its modern-day manifestations, Thanksgiving continues to evolve, reflecting the diverse tapestry of American culture. So, whether you're savoring the traditional turkey dinner, participating in a Friendsgiving celebration, or simply taking a moment of quiet reflection, may your Thanksgiving be filled with gratitude, joy, and an appreciation for the stories that make this holiday uniquely ours.

    Popular Posts